Why You Can't Use Extension Methods With A WebGrid

5 (9 votes)

An interesting question came up recently on the ASP.NET forums. In it, the questioner was attempting to use my Chop() extension method to limit the number of characters in a WebGrid column but it wouldn't work. At first, I was a little stumped, so I tried it myself and got an error message:

'string' does not contain a definition for 'Chop'

 

Huh? The code looked fine:

        grid.Column(
            columnName : "Description",
            format: @<text>@item.Description.Chop(20)</text>
            )

..and the extension method was placed in a class called Extensions within App_Code, so it should have worked, surely? Then I studied the error message a little more closely, and saw this:

Exception Details: Microsoft.CSharp.RuntimeBinder.RuntimeBinderException: 'string' does not contain a definition for 'Chop'

The exception was being thrown by the RuntimeBinder, not the Compiler.

The argument that the WebGridColumn's Format parameter takes is a delegate: Func<dynamic,object>. What this means is that you have to pass in a dynamic type, and then something is done to it before it is returned as an object. A dynamic expression is resolved at runtime. The compiler doesn't know what it is.

When you try to use an extension method, the Compiler will check the type you are trying to use it on to see if such a method exists. If it doesn't. it will check any base classes that the type derives from to see if they contain a formal method with the right name. If that test fails, the Compiler will busy itself looking at any referenced static class which contains a static method with a first argument (the this part of an extension method) of the same type that the method is invoked on. In the case of the Chop method, that would a string. With dynamic variables, that reference isn't passed as part of the "Payload" to the RuntimeBinder, so it cannot find the extension method in your App_Code folder. And that, in the shell of a nut, is why you cannot use extension methods on a dynamic.

Great, so what can you do? Well, the extension method is still a static method on a class, so you can call it like this:

        grid.Column(
            columnName : "Description",
            format: @<text>@Extensions.Chop(item.Description, 20)</text>
            )

Note that this issue doesn't just affect items from a query which are passed to the format method in a WebGrid - it affects all the results you get from a database query because the Database.Query method returns an IEnumerable<dynamic>. That means that you cannot simply apply an extension method in this context either:

@foreach(var item in data){
    @item.Description.Chop(30)<br />
}

One thing you can do in the above example (outside of a WebGrid) is to convert the dynamic return to a strongly typed one. You can use Jeremy Skinners Strongly Type helper for WebMatrix.Data for this (http://www.jeremyskinner.co.uk/2011/01/24/strongly-typed-data-access-with-webmatrix-data/).

If you have problems trying to use extension methods within the WebGridColumn's format argument, or anywhere else on the dynamic return from a method, hopefully you know what to do now. But this example also goes to show that it pays to read exception messages carefully.

 

Date Posted:
Last Updated:
Posted by:
Total Views to date: 12673

2 Comments

- Alistair

Hi Mike, after hitting my head with Use Extension Methods With A WebGrid, i found this article, i tried your suggestion but i keep getting the error below, any ideas?

CS1738: Named argument specifications must appear after all fixed arguments have been specified

- Amir

Thanks mate!

Recent Comments

Jerrie Pelser 23/07/2016 05:08
In response to Loading ASP.NET Core MVC Views From A Database Or Other Location
Very cool concept Mike!...

Satyabrata 20/07/2016 20:54
In response to ASP.NET Web Pages vNext or Razor Pages
Thanks for sharing ...

infocyde 18/07/2016 00:40
In response to ASP.NET Web Pages vNext or Razor Pages
Curious to see if a new release of webmatrix will happen or if that is dead in the water....

Don 15/07/2016 16:58
In response to ASP.NET Web Pages vNext or Razor Pages
Thanks Mike! Wonder if the MVC Lite is the Controllerless Views approach referred to on the Web Dev...

Jose Negro 30/06/2016 16:02
In response to Entity Framework Code First and Stored Procedures
Thank you very much for so clear examples....

A. Truong 29/06/2016 15:25
In response to The Best Way To Import Data From Excel To SQL Server via ASP.NET
Awesome work! Lifesaver....

satyabrata 19/06/2016 18:53
In response to Entity Framework Code First and Stored Procedures
Nice article. Thanks. The menu on this website not working in mobile....

satyabrata 16/05/2016 06:28
In response to Implementing SQL Server Full-Text Search In An ASP.NET MVC Web Application With Entity Framework
This is great. Thanks for sharing....

sharey 06/05/2016 13:15
In response to The Best Way To Import Data From Excel To SQL Server via ASP.NET
nice work gentleman.Really helpfull....

Satyabrata Mohapatra 20/04/2016 04:36
In response to The Best Way To Import Data From Excel To SQL Server via ASP.NET
Another beauty !!!! Thanks for sharing....